Question Tuesday

This week’s question isn’t exactly a wizard rock question, but it is Harry Potter related.

Awhile back, Joshua Herdman (Crabbe) made the claim that Deathly Hallows will be split right after Harry, Ron, and Hermione are grabbed by the Snatchers. David Yates has said he had “three or four different ideas” about where the break would be, so it is still uncertain whether Herdman is correct.

Where would you split the movie?

I always thought that the best place would be after they buried Dobby. It’s not during a real cliffhanger, and I’d hate to see Dobby’s death belittled by being at the beginning of part 2. I’m afraid we will all gloss over that part with all the deaths at the end, and I think Dobby deserves better than that.

4 responses to “Question Tuesday”

  1. Jacquelyn Avatar
    Jacquelyn

    I think just after Dobby’s burial would be perfect too. Any other place and his death won’t receive the recognition it deserves. =(

  2. LunasCeiling Avatar

    I think that would be a great place, too… But honestly, with Kloves’ return as screenwriter with HBP, does anyone really think that any characters who AREN’T the Trio, Snape, or Dumbledore will get anything other than a superficial treatment? I sure don’t. Look how Luna was wasted in the last one…

  3. Zivlok Avatar
    Zivlok

    If Kloves is writing it, Hermione will probably end up killing Voldemort…

    I would like after Dobby’s burial, because I would really enjoy the last movie being entirely taking place on one day. However, I’m not sure they could fit everything before Dobby’s death into the first one. I think being taken by the snatchers, or after Ron kills the locket dealie as being likely choices. Don’t forget all the shit that has to happen even before the locket – the ministry falling, the trio sneaking into the MoM, Ron leaving, Godric’s Hollow, snake lady, the silver doe, Ron returning.

  4. Alex of TWW Avatar

    Joshua Herdman plays Goyle.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *