Question Creevey!

We’ve got your Question Tuesday and Creevey Thursday all rolled into one this week!

I Speak Tree
Tianna of I Speak Tree performing in Pittsburgh.
photo by pretenditious


I Speak Tree just started touring with The Butterbeer Experience and selling her inaugural album, Got Bark?, so it’s been in my CD player for the past few days. My favorite song of hers is ‘Horcruxes’ because it reminds me of my favorite part about wizard rock – getting a different perspective.
The series is so centered around Harry and his experience that sometimes I find it hard to try and see things from someone else’s point of view. But with bands like Tonks and the Aurors, The Remus Lupins, and countless others, we get the chance to see that. ‘Horcruxes’ is a perfect example of this – a glimpse into Hermione’s thoughts while on that endless camping trip.
“Three horcruxes, what are we going to do?
Three horcruxes, trying to destroy you.
Three horcruxes, with four more to go.
Three horcruxes, and we’re not halfway through.”
I’ve heard and agreed with so many complaints about how long the camping trip seemed to drag on in Deathly Hallows. I think that JK Rowling was trying to show us this desperation and endless anxiety, but I never really got it until I listened to ‘Horcruxes’. I love that Tianna was able to accomplish it in four minutes, and I feel the need to reread Deathly Hallows with this new perspective on things.

Do you have a wizard rock song that really just made you think about Harry Potter in a completely different way?

12 responses to “Question Creevey!”

  1. Patrick Avatar
    Patrick

    Seasonal Depression by The Whomping Willows completely messed with me when I first heard it. Dumbeldore has always been my favorite character in the series, and having even a second thought about his methods really spun my head for a little bit.

  2. Andrew Avatar

    Tianna is awesome. One of my favourite new/undiscovered wizard rock artists out there, and she’s fantastic live. (Also, that photo is better than I expected! I didn’t remember getting any particularly great shots from that show, but I guess I underestimate myself… ;))

    As to the actual question, pretty much every MC Kreacher song has given me a new perspective on Kreacher. And the world in general. I love how subversive his lyrics get.

    TRL’s “Bezoar Pills” made me think about Remus and his motivations – the lyrics make a reasonable inference that Dumbledore asked him to stay away, and that made me think about how lonely Remus must have been after losing all of his friends in one fell swoop, and being unable to help Harry in any way. Kind of a downer. (Similarly, OBatR’s “There By My Side” becomes RIDICULOUSLY depressing when you realise that it’s about the Marauders. It took me a few listens to catch on because it’s such a gorgeous and hopeful song, which is what makes the tragedy hit you more starkly.)

  3. Clare Avatar

    We belong together by Kristina Horner of the Parselmouths and Jason Munday of MoM definitely makes you feel for Narcissa (and Lucius), a lot of people didn’t really picture them in love.

    Where can I listen to There by my Side by OBATR? I can’t find it on youtube or his website?

    And yeah, Tianna is awesome.

  4. badger666 Avatar
    badger666

    “The Grave” by Let’s Lumos! It’s the only song I’ve ever heard about the Crouch family and their tragedies, a subject almost completely ignored in both fan fic and wrock.

  5. Marauder Avatar

    I agree with Clare and badger666. This is a really great question – will try to think of other songs.

    Anytime someone wants to tell me how to update the band listings, I am ready and eager. *sparkly eyes*

  6. Freya Avatar

    Clare, I totally agree with that one, too! Perfect example.

  7. Jarrod Avatar
    Jarrod

    I just want to say that I *heart* Tianna. I’m a definite fanboy.

  8. Andrew Avatar

    I can’t find it either Clare, sorry. I think I got it from last.fm a while back, but it doesn’t seem to be there any longer.

    I love it so much though. The mandolin is a beautiful instrument, and wielded by Christian….!

  9. Stine Avatar

    @Clare and Andrew: There By My Side was available as a free download once upon a time – look through the OBatR MySpace blogs and there might still be a working link. It’s also available as a bonus track on the Bare Bones EP.

    As song that comes to mind for me is Home by The Remus Lupins. It puts Remus’ decision to leave Tonks in a slightly more redeeming light, and whether or not it completely agrees with canon, it’s nice hearing the story from that perspective. (On the other hand, Tonks and the Aurors have several songs that make Remus leaving feel more upsetting than ever. Sigh.)

  10. badger666 Avatar
    badger666

    I got “There By My Side” and “In Your Shadow” as free downloads from oliverboydandtheremembralls.com, not his Myspace. You can check there to see if they are still available.

  11. LunasCeiling Avatar

    “Not a Hero” by His Silver Hand got me thinking about Peter Pettigrew in ways I’d NEVER have though t possible.

  12. Avery Avatar
    Avery

    “Petunia” by Riddle TM really got me thinking. I never really thought about Petunia missing Lily before, but now I realize it must have been very hard on her.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *